Josh seemed equal parts turned on and proud of himself, so I rewarded him with a kiss, licking Margot’s taste off his lips. She didn’t move as he and I kissed, but I heard her intake of breath as she watched us, and I figured she’d be ready to go again soon.
“Is it time to reciprocate?” she whispered when Josh and I pulled apart. She sat up, reaching out to Josh and pulling him closer. Before he could say anything, she had him in her mouth, sucking him deep. He was thick and hard, gliding in and out of her mouth, and it was sexy as fuck. So much so, I needed a taste too. I leaned over and nudged her hand out of the way, giving me room to lick the underside of his shaft while she continued to suck the tip. Josh dug his fingers into our hair, holding us close as we worked him in tandem.
She moved away and I put my mouth where hers had been. I’d never done this before and wasn’t sure how I felt about it, but in the moment, it felt like nothing but sexy fun. He groaned when I sucked him deep into my mouth, and I figured I’d give this my best shot because it might be the only time I ever did it. I took him as deep as I could, getting new appreciation for women who did this, but like everything else tonight, all it did was turn me on. I’d fantasized about this a million times, wondering what it was like since I loved being on the receiving end, and the reality freaked me out a little. It was hot and sensual and wild, but for the first time in my adult life, I was unsure of myself.
Was I doing it right? Was it what it was supposed to be? Was Margot better at it?
“God, that’s beautiful,” Josh moaned.
I glanced up and the look of pleasure in his eyes made me forget everything else. He still had his fingers in my hair, and in Margot’s as well, staring down at us as if we were literally his fantasy. Which turned me on all over again. Since I had no plans to do something like this again, I was going to make the most of it. I closed my eyes and pulled him deeper into my mouth. Everything about this was foreign but also everything I’d hoped it would be.
Margot was sucking one of Josh’s balls and I recognized the signs that he was on the verge of coming. So I sucked harder, taking him as deep as I could, and sure enough, he shot off into my mouth. Damn, was I that good or was it beginner’s luck? I almost laughed but managed a smirk as I looked up again.
“How is it I’m the only one who hasn’t gotten off yet?” I asked, wiping my mouth with the back of my hand.
Josh grinned and reached into the bedside table for lube and…a glove? Oh Jesus, I knew what this meant, and I wasn’t sure I was ready.
“Well, that’s about to change,” Josh said. “Margot’s going to suck your dick while I massage your prostate.”
“Fuck yeah.” I’d experienced ass play with women, so it wasn’t new, but doing it with a guy was.
Margot had me in her mouth before I had a chance to think about anything else, and Josh was beside her. They alternated sucking my cock just like she and I had done to him, except he had his finger in my ass now, and the sensations zipping through me were un-fucking-believable. I wasn’t going to last long at all. Between the pressure of Margot’s soft little mouth and the things Josh was doing with his finger, I had the stamina of a thirteen-year-old. I held on as long as I could, but it felt so good I came embarrassingly fast.
“That’s fucking hot,” Josh said, his eyes lustful and glazed as he watched me.
“Yeah, it is.” I nudged them both onto the bed and put Margot between us. I wasn’t embarrassed, but maybe a touch overwhelmed. I was pretty adventurous sexually, but fulfilling this particular fantasy was heady stuff, so I focused on Margot. I brushed her hair out of her face and kissed her, taking deep, erotic pulls of her tongue until Josh pushed me out of the way and took over. We did that for a few minutes, and I reached out to cup one of her full, round breasts. I ran my thumb over the nipple, loving how it hardened under my touch, and Josh mimicked my movements. Now it was his turn to be overwhelmed, which was equal parts sexy and fun to watch.
Margot squirmed between us, reaching out to stroke both of our cocks.
“You’re so ready to be fucked, aren’t you, baby?” I whispered.
She licked her lips, looking from one of us to the other as she nodded.
“Hands and knees,” I whispered to her. She got into position quickly and Josh lay on his back so he could continue kissing her. I slowly took out the plug she’d been wearing and was glad to see Jamie had given her a big one. Hopefully, that would make what I was about to do easier. Not all women liked anal, but I really wanted Margot to because it wasn’t any fun for me if the woman wasn’t enjoying herself. Especially since Josh was going to do her at the same time.
I poured a decent amount of lube between the cheeks of her ass and rubbed it in before sheathing myself with a condom.
“You ready?” I whispered, running my hand down her back.
“Yes.” Her voice was a muffled whisper, and I motioned to Josh to keep kissing her.
I put the head of my cock at her tight little hole and pushed, slowly but firmly. She clenched at first, but I reached down and found her clit, circling it slowly, and as soon as I did that, she relaxed. I pushed inside of her, just the tip at first, and then a little more. To my surprise, she pushed back against me, and I followed her lead, getting deeper and deeper until I was all the way inside of her.
“Margot? You okay?”
“Mmmm…” Her only response was a long, sexy moan, and it was a beautiful sound.
“God, that’s hot.” Josh was watching us, his cock stiff and hard again, ready to go. I wasn’t ready to share her yet and I picked up speed, sliding in and out of her with a little more finesse.
“More,” she whispered.
“Fuck.” I moved faster, going harder, until she was grinding against me. Damn, Margot was full of surprises.
“You ready for the rest?” I asked her, trying to slow my own heartbeat and stay in control. I didn’t want to come until both of us were inside of her at the same time, and I stopped moving.
“Yes.”
I pulled out and rolled onto my back, propping a few pillows behind my head so I was sitting up just a little. “Then hop up here and sit on my cock.”
She hesitated but then crawled on top of me, her eyes meeting mine. We stared at each other for a moment, something shifting between us. There was all this sexy stuff happening, but her trust in me, to make her feel good and to guide Josh in that department, showed me there was more to us than a night of sexual fantasies. For a split second we were alone, our gazes locked intently, but then Josh moved into my field of vision and I remembered the task at hand.
“Other way,” I said gently. “Because then you’re going to lie back and Josh is going to get on top of you.”
“Oh, shit.” Her eyes rounded, as if she hadn’t quite thought this through, but I just held her hips as she squatted on my crotch. I guided my cock back to her ass and she sank down slowly, letting out a breath as I filled her.
Josh was watching us, cautiously pushing a finger into her vagina. “You’re so wet,” he said, a little awe in his voice. “That’s good, right? How it’s supposed to be?”
“Oh, yeah.” She nodded. “Take me, Josh.”
“Honey, I might not be any good at this.” His voice was gravelly, with a touch of trepidation.